Steady and Stable... Don't chase quick hits...

Unreasonable Expectations?

We received a phone call the other day that got us thinking. The call came in from a former client who was an acquisitions specialist for a developer. He no longer works for the company that he used to work for ---that developer is still trying to liquidate the surplus of units that they overbuilt in 2005-2009. This person is now working for a “value investor fund”. He called us to tell us about his new job and to solicit our help looking for real estate investments. He engaged us in conversation. He is looking for deals--- he is now what we call a “Scout”.

He outlined what his new company’s investment criteria. “We are ready to buy… We will buy Office, Medical Office, or Retail.” “We have a group of investors that are ready to fund.” “We have promised our investors a 20% return…”

Oh really? I reply… I then wonder; why are you wasting your time and ours? If you are looking for 20+% annual returns from commercial real estate you might as well be buying lottery tickets…

Here is why we believe that. Let’s look at a bit of math… Assume you have a million dollars to invest. If you are seeking a 20% compounded rate of return that means that a million dollars invested for five years with no cash flow for the first five years would have to be sold for and net $2.488 million dollars. So in five years the Asset has to appreciate nearly 2.5 times. But that doesn’t even consider the “value add expenses”. Say the subject property is 10,000 square feet. Assume you do cosmetic and tenant improvements that cost $30 per square foot and leasing commissions that cost $5 per square foot. Initial Investment plus improvements are now $1,350,000. To achieve a 20% return in 5 years, the property now has to be sold for $3.359 million.

To us it is difficult if not impossible to imagine a scenario in which a $1 million dollar property will become worth $3.359 million in five years. The income to justify a $3.359 million dollar sales price at a 9% cap rate 5 years from now would be more than $2.51 per square foot per month triple net.

To imagine a scenario like this occurring we’ll have to go through another cycle—money will freely flow, lending restrictions will ease, prices will increase, more money will come in, and things will get out of control again. It has happened before –and probably will happen again --but we doubt this is the likely scenario any time soon.

Scouts are likely to become frustrated and begin to question whether the chance for quick money and high double digit returns will be attainable at all this time. My gray hair and experience in the commercial real estate business leads me to believe it’s probably more reasonable to expect that a combination of extended consumer de-leveraging and ongoing economic funk will temper lending practices and hamstring demand for years to come. Financial reform will likely bring more restrictions on deal making too. The speculative bubble has burst and very few dollars are going to be made in “distressed real estate” in the short term.

We wish all investors happy hunting and there certainly may be one-off opportunities in the distressed market… We suspect that real estate investors will be better served to stop looking for the distressed quick trading hits. We’re just not going back to the “crazy good old days of 2005” anytime soon. At this point of the real estate cycle we believe that most investors should be focusing on building good core portfolios of well-leased income producing properties, grounded in good fundamentals. Investors should focus on achieving year-in, year out returns in the high single digits where annualized real estate returns historically perform. If values escalate again, these properties will almost certainly jump ahead of the curve so you’ll be in a great position to sell out. That’s why the top properties in the best markets make sense.

People can try to play the yo-yo game of finding rare jewels. But let’s face it--right now the economy and lenders just won’t cooperate. This time around we believe that conventional wisdom may take a lot longer to play out. Steady 8% returns not quick 20% returns is the more likely bet!

If we can be of service reviewing evaluating or finding commercial investment real estate or if you would like to continue the debate over which type of commercial real estate will achieve the best performance please call Jim Gray or Nahz Anvary (916) 375-1500 or at jim&nahz@ctbt.com.